Skip to content
Menu

Consistency, News and Other Trading Rules

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Why firms have these rules
  2. Consistency rules
  3. News trading rules
  4. Overnight and weekend holding
  5. Automated trading and copy trading
  6. Commonly banned strategies
  7. Avoiding accidental breaches
  8. Key takeaways

In this lesson you will learn

  • Explain how consistency rules are calculated
  • Describe common news trading and weekend holding rules
  • Recognize banned strategies and practices
  • Check a firm's rules before trading to avoid accidental breaches

The last two lessons covered loss limits. Firms also set rules about how you trade and how your profits are spread. This lesson explains consistency rules, news trading rules, weekend and overnight holding, automated and copy trading, and the strategies firms commonly ban. Breaking one of these rules can fail a challenge or cancel a payout, even when you stayed inside every loss limit.

Why firms have these rules

Prop firms want traders who can make steady profits with controlled risk. They also want to avoid strategies that exploit simulated conditions in ways that would not work in a real market. Most trading rules aim to:

  • stop one lucky trade or day from counting as skill
  • avoid trading during moments when prices jump and simulated fills may be unrealistic
  • block strategies that cannot lose in a simulation but would in reality

Consistency rules

A consistency rule limits how much of your total profit can come from a single day or trade. It is usually written as a percentage.

Worked example (illustrative numbers): a firm has a 40% consistency rule based on the best day. Over a challenge, you make 10,000 US dollars of total profit, and your best day made 5,000. Your best day is 50% of total profit, so you do not meet the rule. To meet it, total profit would need to reach at least 12,500 (5,000 ÷ 0.40) with no larger day.

ExampleNowTotal 10,000Best day 5,00040% of totalBest day 50%: rule not metNeededTotal 12,500Best day 5,00040% of totalBest day 40%: rule metNeeded total = 5,000 ÷ 0.40 = 12,500, with no larger day
With a 5,000 best day and a 40% rule, total profit must reach 12,500 before the best day is a small enough share.

Firms apply consistency rules in different ways:

  • Best day as a share of total profit, as above.
  • Lot size consistency, where trade sizes must stay within a range of your average.
  • Applied at payout, on funded accounts, rather than during the challenge.

Consistency rules usually do not fail an account outright. Instead, you may need to keep trading until the ratio is met before you can pass or request a payout. The practical effect is that trading at an even size with steady risk is safer than a few large trades.

News trading rules

Major economic releases, such as interest rate decisions and employment reports, can cause sharp price moves, wide spreads and slippage. Many firms restrict trading around them.

Common versions:

  • No trading within a window, such as a few minutes before and after high-impact releases. Opening or closing trades in this window may break the rule, or profits from such trades may be removed.
  • Allowed in the challenge, restricted on funded accounts.
  • No restriction, at some firms.

Check which news events count. Many firms use a specific economic calendar and only the highest-impact events. The fundamental analysis course lesson on the economic calendar explains how to read release schedules. A stop-loss or take-profit triggered inside the window may also count, so close or adjust positions before the window if the rule requires it.

Overnight and weekend holding

Some firms let you hold positions overnight and over weekends; others require all positions to be closed before the market closes on Friday, or offer this only on certain account types. Weekend gaps can make prices open far from Friday's close, skipping stop-losses. Positions held overnight also pay or receive swap at rollover, which affects your daily loss calculation.

Automated trading and copy trading

Rules on Expert Advisors and copy trading vary:

  • EAs may be allowed, allowed with conditions, or banned. Firms often ban EAs that exploit latency or that many traders use at once.
  • Copy trading between your own accounts may be allowed. Copying signals or other traders, or having someone else trade your account, is often banned.
  • Trade copiers between firms can raise questions if they look like account management or hedging across accounts.

Ask the firm in writing if you plan to use any automation.

Commonly banned strategies

Firm rules differ, but the following are often prohibited:

  • Hedging across accounts, for example buying on one account and selling the same market on another, so one passes whatever happens.
  • Latency arbitrage, exploiting delays between price feeds.
  • Tick scalping or very short holding times below a minimum, at some firms; ordinary scalping is often allowed.
  • Martingale or grid systems without stops, at some firms.
  • Gap trading, opening large positions right before weekend or session gaps, at some firms.
  • Gambling behavior, such as risking most of the account on one trade.
  • Account sharing, letting someone else trade for you, or passing challenges for others.

Hedging within a single account, holding a buy and sell on the same market, may be allowed or banned depending on the firm.

Avoiding accidental breaches

Most rule breaches are accidents caused by not reading the rules carefully. A simple process:

  1. Read the full rules and FAQ before buying, not only the summary table.
  2. List every trading rule on one page beside your loss limits.
  3. Add news times to your daily routine, and close or avoid trades around them if required.
  4. Keep size consistent, which helps with consistency and lot size rules.
  5. Ask in writing about anything unclear, and keep the reply.
  6. Check for rule changes before each new challenge or payout.

Key takeaways

  • Consistency rules limit how much profit can come from one day or trade; steady size helps meet them.
  • News rules often ban opening or closing trades in a window around major releases.
  • Weekend and overnight rules vary; gaps and swaps both carry risk.
  • EAs, copy trading and certain strategies may be restricted or banned.
  • Read the full rules, write them down and ask in writing about anything unclear.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A firm has a 40% consistency rule. Total profit is 10,000 US dollars and the best day made 5,000. Does this meet the rule?

    • A. Yes, 50% is under 40%
    • B. No, the best day is 50% of total profit, above 40%
    • C. Yes, consistency rules only apply to losses
    • D. It depends on the spread
    Show answer

    B. No, the best day is 50% of total profit, above 40%

  2. 2. What is a common news rule at prop firms?

    • A. No trades may be opened or closed within a few minutes of major releases
    • B. Trades must be opened only during news
    • C. News trading doubles the profit split
    • D. News rules apply only to stocks
    Show answer

    A. No trades may be opened or closed within a few minutes of major releases

  3. 3. Which practice is commonly banned by prop firms?

    • A. Using a stop-loss
    • B. Hedging the same market across two accounts to guarantee one passes
    • C. Trading during the main session
    • D. Keeping a journal
    Show answer

    B. Hedging the same market across two accounts to guarantee one passes

Prop firms to try this with

Put this into practice on a demo account first, with no money at risk.