Skip to content
Menu

How Prop Firm Evaluations Work

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. The goal of an evaluation
  2. The core rules
  3. Turning percentages into money
  4. How passing works
  5. What a rule sheet looks like
  6. Details that catch traders out
  7. Practicing the rules
  8. Fees, refunds and resets
  9. Key takeaways

In this lesson you will learn

  • Name the main rules found in a prop firm evaluation
  • Calculate targets and limits in money from percentages
  • Explain minimum trading days and time limits
  • Read a challenge rule sheet and spot the details that matter

The first lesson described the prop firm model. This lesson looks inside the evaluation itself. You will learn the main rules you will meet, how to convert them from percentages into money, how time rules work, and what to read carefully on a rule sheet before you pay.

The goal of an evaluation

An evaluation checks two things: that you can make a profit, and that you can control losses while doing it. Firms care more about the second. A trader who makes a large profit by taking huge risks is likely to lose the firm's money later. So most rules limit losses, and only one rule asks for profit.

The core rules

Profit target

The profit target is the gain you must reach to pass a phase. It is set as a percentage of the starting balance.

Daily loss limit

The daily loss limit is the most you may lose in one trading day. If you reach it, the challenge usually fails, even if you were in profit overall. The daily loss limits lesson explains how firms calculate it.

Maximum loss (maximum drawdown)

The maximum loss is the most your account may fall in total. It can be fixed from the starting balance, or it can move up as your account grows. The drawdown types lesson covers each version.

Minimum trading days

Many challenges require you to trade on a minimum number of days before you can pass. This stops traders from passing with one lucky trade.

Time limit

Some challenges give a set number of days to reach the target. Others have no time limit. Time limits add pressure, which is why many firms have removed them.

Trading rules

Firms also set rules on how you trade: leverage limits, whether you can hold trades overnight or over the weekend, whether you can trade during news, and whether Expert Advisors or copy trading are allowed. The consistency and news rules lesson covers these.

Turning percentages into money

Rules are written as percentages, but you trade in money. Convert them before you start.

Worked example (illustrative numbers): a 50,000 US dollar challenge with these rules:

  • profit target 8%: 50,000 × 0.08 = 4,000 US dollars
  • daily loss limit 5%: 50,000 × 0.05 = 2,500 US dollars
  • maximum loss 10%: 50,000 × 0.10 = 5,000 US dollars
  • minimum trading days: 4

To pass, the account must reach 54,000 US dollars on at least 4 trading days without ever falling below 45,000 and without losing more than 2,500 in any single day.

Notice the relationship: the target (4,000) is smaller than the maximum loss (5,000), but not by much. You need a method where gains outpace losses while staying well inside both limits. Write the money figures on a note beside your screen.

How passing works

When you reach the target and meet the other conditions, such as minimum days, you pass the phase. Some firms check automatically; others review your account first. During review, the firm may check that you followed all trading rules. A rule break found at this stage can still fail the challenge, so read the rules fully.

ExamplePhase 1target +10%loss limitsPhase 2target +5%same limitsFundedfirm's capitalsame limitsPayoutprofit split,e.g. 80%repeats each cyclerule breachAccount closedbuy a new challenge or a reset to try again
A two-phase challenge leads to a funded account and repeat payouts, while a rule breach at any stage ends the account.

Depending on the challenge type, passing leads to a second phase or straight to a funded account. The next lesson compares the types.

What a rule sheet looks like

A typical rule sheet lists:

  • account size and fee
  • profit target for each phase
  • daily loss limit and how it is calculated
  • maximum loss and its type
  • minimum trading days and any time limit
  • leverage for each asset class
  • allowed and banned strategies
  • news and weekend rules
  • profit split and payout schedule on the funded account
  • whether the fee is refunded

Details that catch traders out

Several details are easy to miss:

  • Balance or equity? Some limits are based on closed balance, others on equity, which includes open profit and loss. An open losing trade can break an equity-based limit even if you have not closed it.
  • When does the day reset? The daily limit usually resets at a set server time, which may not match your local midnight.
  • Does open profit count toward the target? Usually the target must be reached with closed trades.
  • Are commissions and swaps included? Costs reduce your result and count against your limits.
  • What counts as a trading day? Often a day with at least one trade opened or closed.

If the rules do not answer these questions clearly, ask the firm in writing before you buy.

Practicing the rules

Before paying, trade a demo account with the same rules for a few weeks. Track your daily results against the daily limit and your overall drawdown against the maximum. If your normal trading would have broken a rule, adjust your risk per trade or choose a challenge with rules that suit you. The position size calculator helps you set risk that fits the limits.

Fees, refunds and resets

The fee is part of the evaluation design. Some firms refund it with the first payout from a funded account. Some offer a free retry if you finish the time limit in profit without breaking a rule. Others sell a reset, which restarts the challenge for a lower price than a new one. Include these terms when you compare challenges, because they change the real cost of each attempt.

Key takeaways

  • An evaluation tests profit and loss control, with most rules limiting losses.
  • The core rules are a profit target, daily loss limit, maximum loss, minimum days and sometimes a time limit.
  • Convert every percentage into money before you trade.
  • Check whether limits use balance or equity, when the day resets and whether costs count.
  • Practice the exact rules on demo before paying for a challenge.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A 50,000 US dollar challenge has an 8% profit target. How much profit is needed?

    • A. 400 US dollars
    • B. 4,000 US dollars
    • C. 8,000 US dollars
    • D. 40,000 US dollars
    Show answer

    B. 4,000 US dollars

  2. 2. What happens if you break the maximum loss rule during a challenge?

    • A. You get a warning only
    • B. The challenge usually ends immediately
    • C. The target is lowered
    • D. The fee is refunded
    Show answer

    B. The challenge usually ends immediately

  3. 3. What is a minimum trading days rule?

    • A. You must trade on at least a set number of days before you can pass
    • B. You can only trade on weekends
    • C. You must hold every trade for a day
    • D. You must trade every single day
    Show answer

    A. You must trade on at least a set number of days before you can pass

Prop firms to try this with

Put this into practice on a demo account first, with no money at risk.