Choosing a Stock Broker
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
In this lesson you will learn
- Check a broker's regulation and investor protection
- Match a broker's markets and account types to your plan
- Compare total costs for your own trading pattern
- Use a checklist to choose and test a broker
This final lesson brings the course together. You now know how the market works, what to buy, how to order it, what it costs, which accounts to use and how to build a portfolio. The last step is choosing where to hold it. You will learn how to check a broker's safety, match its offer to your plan, compare total costs, and test it before committing. Our stock broker reviews apply these checks to individual brokers.
Step 1: Regulation and protection
Safety comes first. A broker holds your money and your shares, so check:
- Regulation: Is the broker authorized by a recognized regulator in your country or region? Look up the firm on the regulator's online register yourself, using its exact legal name and registration number, rather than the broker's website.
- Which entity: Large brokers often have several companies in different countries. Make sure the entity that will hold your account is the regulated one you expect.
- Client asset protection: Regulated brokers are usually required to keep client money and assets separate from their own, known as segregated funds.
- Compensation schemes: In many countries, an investor compensation scheme can cover certain losses, up to a limit, if a regulated firm fails and cannot return client assets. Examples include the UK FSCS and the US SIPC. These schemes do not cover losses from falling share prices.
Step 2: Markets and products
Make sure the broker offers what your plan needs:
- the exchanges and countries you want to invest in
- individual shares, ETFs, funds and bonds, as needed
- fractional shares, if you invest small amounts
- automatic regular investing and dividend reinvestment, if you want them
Some platforms focus on a small list of popular shares; others give access to many exchanges. More choice matters only if you will use it.
Step 3: Account types
Check which accounts are available:
- regular taxable accounts
- tax-advantaged accounts such as ISAs, SIPPs or IRAs, depending on where you live, as covered in the tax-advantaged accounts lesson
- joint accounts or accounts for children, if relevant
- multi-currency accounts, which can reduce FX costs
Step 4: Total costs for your pattern
Costs depend on how you invest. Write down your pattern:
- typical trade size
- number of trades per month or year
- markets and currencies
- account value
Then calculate the yearly cost at each broker you are considering, using the categories from the fees lesson: commissions, FX fees, account fees, inactivity fees and withdrawal fees.
Worked example (illustrative numbers): an investor puts 300 pounds a month into US-listed ETFs and makes no other trades.
- Broker A: no commission, 0.15% FX fee, no account fee. Yearly cost: 3,600 × 0.0015 = about 5.40 pounds in FX fees.
- Broker B: 3 pounds commission per trade, no FX fee because it holds dollars, 0.25% yearly account fee on a 10,000 pound portfolio. Yearly cost: 12 × 3 = 36 pounds plus 25 pounds = 61 pounds.
For this pattern, Broker A is cheaper. A trader making large, infrequent trades might find the opposite. The cost of trade calculator helps compare.
Step 5: Platform and tools
Check that the platform suits you:
- clear order entry with the order types you need, as in the order types lesson
- useful research, such as company data, news and charts
- a reliable mobile app
- clear statements, tax reports and cost reports
The trading platforms course explains what to look for in more detail.
Step 6: Account opening and funding
- Verification: Regulated brokers must verify your identity, known as KYC. Expect to provide identification and proof of address.
- Deposits and withdrawals: Check the methods, fees and how long withdrawals take.
- Minimum deposit: Many brokers have none or a low minimum; some have higher minimums.
Step 7: Support and reliability
- Can you reach support by your preferred method, in your language?
- Does the broker publish clear answers about fees, protections and corporate actions?
- Do independent reports suggest the platform is reliable during busy market periods?
Red flags
- not listed on a recognized regulator's register, or the registration does not match
- pressure to deposit quickly, or calls from "account managers" pushing trades
- promises of guaranteed returns
- unclear or hidden fees
- difficulty withdrawing money
If you see these, do not deposit.
Step 8: Test before committing
Start small. Open the account, make a small deposit, buy a small position, and make a small withdrawal. This checks the full process: verification, funding, trading, statements and withdrawals. Once you are comfortable, move larger amounts or set up regular investing.
Moving brokers later
If you change your mind, many brokers allow transfers of shares and funds to another broker without selling them, often called an in-specie or ACATS transfer depending on the country. Fractional shares and some funds may not transfer. Check transfer fees before opening the account.
Keep your records
Once you open an account, keep copies of the account agreement, the fee schedule at the time you joined, and your annual statements. Brokers update their terms from time to time, and having the original documents makes it easier to spot changes in costs or protections. Your statements also help with tax returns, especially if you hold foreign shares that pay dividends with withholding tax.
Key takeaways
- Check regulation on the regulator's own register, and understand client asset protection and compensation limits.
- Make sure the broker offers your markets, products and account types.
- Compare total yearly costs using your own trade size, frequency and currencies.
- Check the platform, verification, funding, withdrawals and support.
- Start with a small deposit and test the full process, including a withdrawal.
Check your understanding
1. What should you check first when choosing a stock broker?
- A. The app's colors
- B. Regulation by a recognized authority and how client assets are protected
- C. The number of social media followers
- D. Whether it offers the highest leverage
Show answer
B. Regulation by a recognized authority and how client assets are protected
2. What does an investor compensation scheme usually cover?
- A. Losses from falling share prices
- B. Certain losses if a regulated firm fails and cannot return client assets, up to a limit
- C. Trading fees
- D. Taxes
Show answer
B. Certain losses if a regulated firm fails and cannot return client assets, up to a limit
3. Why compare costs using your own trading pattern?
- A. Because the cheapest broker depends on trade size, frequency and markets
- B. Because all brokers charge the same
- C. Because fees never change
- D. Because costs only matter for large accounts
Show answer
A. Because the cheapest broker depends on trade size, frequency and markets
Stock brokers to put this into practice
Put this into practice on a demo account first, with no money at risk.
Trading 2124.8 / 5Visit
XTB4.5 / 5Visit
Interactive Brokers4.5 / 5Visit