Is CommSec Safe?
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated · How we make money
On this page
Yes, CommSec is a safe place to hold shares. Commonwealth Securities Limited holds license AFSL 238814 from ASIC, is owned by the Commonwealth Bank of Australia, and has operated since 1995. The points to understand are that the bank does not guarantee CommSec, and Australia has no compensation scheme for broker failure.
Regulated entities
| Entity | Regulator | License | Serves | Negative balance protection | Compensation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Commonwealth Securities Limited | ASIC | AFSL 238814 | Australia | Not stated | None, None |
CommSec's company
Commonwealth Securities Limited holds AFSL 238814 and serves Australia. It is supervised by ASIC, which sets conduct and client-money rules for Australian financial services licensees.
Bank ownership and what "non-guaranteed" means
CommSec is a wholly owned, non-guaranteed subsidiary of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX: CBA).Being owned by a large bank brings a strong parent, established systems and close regulatory attention. But "non-guaranteed" means the bank has not promised to cover CommSec's debts if it failed. Your protection comes from CommSec's own license obligations and from how your assets are held, not from the bank's balance sheet.
How your ASX shares are held
ASX shares bought through CommSec are usually held on the CHESS sub-register under your own Holder Identification Number (HIN). That means the shares are registered in your name, not the broker's. If CommSec failed, your HIN holdings would stay yours and could be moved to another broker.
International shares are held through custodians overseas, in a structure for CommSec clients. Those holdings are protected by segregation rather than by direct registration in your name.
How your cash is held
Cash for ASX trades sits in a Commonwealth Direct Investment Account, a bank account with the Commonwealth Bank. It earns interest: Commonwealth Direct Investment Account (settlement account) from 13 November 2026: 0.85% under AUD 50,000, 1.60% to AUD 249,999, 2.25% to AUD 999,999 and 2.95% from AUD 1 million; SMSF accounts 2.40% to 3.25%. Because it is a bank deposit, it falls under Australia's bank deposit rules rather than broker client-money rules.
No investor compensation scheme
Australia has no scheme like the UK's FSCS or the US's SIPC that pays investors when a broker fails. A worked example: an investor holds AUD 200,000 of ASX shares on a CommSec HIN. Because the shares are registered in the investor's name, a CommSec failure would not put them at risk, even without a compensation scheme. Fall in market value is a separate risk no scheme covers.
Margin lending
Margin lending lets you borrow against your portfolio. It is regulated, but it magnifies losses, and a margin call can force you to add money or sell at a bad time. It is the main way a CommSec client can lose more than expected.
Phone support for problems
When something goes wrong with an account, being able to call matters. CommSec publishes phone lines open Monday to Friday 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. and 7 days 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. Sydney time on separate lines; international trading support 24 hours on US trading days. That is a real advantage for urgent problems such as a suspected unauthorized login, which you should report at once.
How to check the license
- Search ASIC Connect for AFSL 238814 and confirm the name Commonwealth Securities Limited.
- Check your HIN on your CHESS holding statement.
- Log in only through the official CommSec website or app, and turn on two-factor authentication.
Reputation
The CommSec app scores 4.2 on the App Store and 3.4 on Google Play. Trustpilot shows 1.6 from 45 reviews. No regulator fines or enforcement actions against CommSec are on public record.
How protection compares with Stake and Interactive Brokers
- CommSec: AFSL 238814, bank-owned, ASX shares on your own HIN.
- Stake: AFSL 548196 (authorized representative no. 1241398), US shares covered by SIPC up to USD 500,000 including USD 250,000 cash.
- Interactive Brokers: AFSL 453554, part of a listed US group.
CommSec's registration of ASX shares in your name is a strong protection. For US shares, Stake's SIPC cover is a clearer safety net than CommSec's overseas custody.
Related pages
Back to the full CommSec review.
Frequently asked questions
Is CommSec regulated?
Yes. Commonwealth Securities Limited holds an Australian financial services license and is supervised by ASIC.
Does the Commonwealth Bank guarantee CommSec?
No. CommSec is a wholly owned but non-guaranteed subsidiary, so the bank does not guarantee its obligations.
What happens to my shares if CommSec fails?
Client assets are held separately from CommSec's own under ASIC rules, so they should be returned to you. Australia has no general compensation scheme to cover a shortfall.
Is my cash at CommSec protected?
Settlement cash sits in a Commonwealth Bank deposit account, which is a bank deposit rather than money held by the broker.