Collective2 Review
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated · How we make money
On this page
- Collective2 at a glance
- Is Collective2 safe?
- How AutoTrade works
- What it costs
- Hypothetical results and certification
- How Collective2 compares
- Scaling and account size
- Futures and options carry extra risk
- Collective2 Europe in practice
- Reading a strategy page
- Customer support
- What users say
- Risks and open questions
- Who Collective2 suits
- User reviews
Collective2 is one of the oldest strategy marketplaces, founded in 2001 and based in New York, United States. Strategy managers publish systems in Stocks, Options, Futures, Forex, and investors copy them into their own broker accounts with AutoTrade. That range is wider than almost any forex signal service. This review explains how copying works, what it really costs each month, what the results on strategy pages mean, which broker holds your money, and how Collective2 compares with other services on this site.
- Founded
- 2001
- Trustpilot
- 1.6 / 5
Collective2 at a glance
Collective2 is a long-running, multi-asset marketplace where costs come from fixed monthly fees rather than wider spreads. Collective2 is privately owned. In the EU the service runs as Collective2 Europe, a brand of MEXEM Ltd (Cyprus, CySEC CIF license 325/17), with broker accounts opened through MEXEM as an introducing broker to Interactive Brokers.
Its strengths are breadth and choice: futures, options and stocks as well as forex, and eight partner brokers including Interactive Brokers. A free account lets you browse strategies and use the simulator. Its weaknesses are cost and evidence. Outside the EU, a single strategy can cost well over 100 a month before any trading result, and most results shown on strategy pages are hypothetical rather than from real accounts. Trustpilot users rate it 1.6 from 33 reviews.
Copying a strategy hands the trading decisions to someone else but leaves every loss with you. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
Can you open an account from your country?
Collective2 does not publish a list of restricted countries.
Pros
- Strategies across stocks, options, futures and forex
- AutoTrade works with eight partner brokers, including Interactive Brokers
- Free account to browse strategies and use the simulator
- AutoTrade is free for EU investors through Collective2 Europe
- Running since 2001
Cons
- AutoTrade plans cost USD 49 to 299 a month outside the EU
- Strategy fees are extra, usually USD 50 to 200 a month
- Results on strategy pages are labeled hypothetical
- No refund policy is published
- Trustpilot score of 1.6 from 33 reviews
Is Collective2 safe?
Collective2 is a technology platform, not a broker. It does not hold client money. Your funds stay at the broker you link, and that broker's regulation decides whether your money is segregated and which compensation scheme covers you.
Partner brokers include Interactive Brokers, Tradovate, TradePro, GarWood, AMP, FXCM, AutoShares, StoneX (Gain Capital). Several are large, regulated firms. Interactive Brokers, for example, is regulated in the US, the UK, the EU and elsewhere. Futures brokers on the list are typically regulated in the US. Check which company your account is opened with.
In the EU, the service runs as Collective2 Europe, a brand of MEXEM Ltd, a Cyprus investment firm licensed by CySEC. MEXEM opens accounts as an introducing broker to Interactive Brokers. For EU investors, that gives a regulated chain from the copy service to the broker.
Collective2 does not publish a list of restricted countries. Availability depends on the broker you link.
How AutoTrade works
AutoTrade copies a strategy's trades into your broker account. Delivery is via AutoTrade to a linked brokerage account. Web platform (strategy pages and trade history)..
- Open a free Collective2 account and browse strategies.
- Review a strategy's history, drawdown and certification.
- Open or link an account at a partner broker.
- Subscribe to the strategy and choose an AutoTrade plan.
- Set the scaling, which is how large your positions are relative to the strategy.
- Collective2 sends each trade to your broker as the strategy trades.
- Cancel the strategy or the plan at any time.
Trade frequency depends on the strategy. Some strategies trade several times a day, others a few times a month. A strategy that trades often can cost more in commissions than one that trades rarely.
What it costs
Plans
| Plan | Price | Period | Includes |
|---|---|---|---|
| AutoTrade, 1 strategy | USD 49 | month | AutoTrade one strategystrategy subscription fees are extra |
| AutoTrade, 3 strategies | USD 99 | month | AutoTrade up to three strategies |
| AutoTrade, 5 strategies | USD 199 | month | AutoTrade up to five strategies |
| AutoTrade, unlimited | USD 299 | month | AutoTrade unlimited strategies |
| Strategy subscription | Usually USD 50 to 200 | month | Set by each strategy manager |
| Collective2 Europe AutoTrade | Free | Not published | AutoTrade for EU investors with a Collective2 (MEXEM) broker account; strategy fees and broker commissions apply |
Collective2's costs come in three layers outside the EU:
- An AutoTrade plan. USD 49 a month for one strategy, rising to USD 299 for unlimited strategies.
- A strategy fee. Usually USD 50 to 200 a month, set by each manager.
- Broker costs. Commissions, spreads and financing on every copied trade.
In the EU, the first layer goes away: AutoTrade for EU investors with a Collective2 (MEXEM) broker account; strategy fees and broker commissions apply.
A worked example with illustrative figures. Outside the EU, you copy one strategy charging 100 a month, on the one-strategy plan of 49. That is 149 a month, or 1,788 a year, before broker costs. On a 20,000 account, the strategy must return about 9% a year just to cover the fees. On a 5,000 account, it must return about 36%. Fixed fees hit small accounts hardest.
Collective2 does not publish a refund policy. Check the terms before you pay for a month you might not use.
Hypothetical results and certification
Collective2 makes no platform-wide claim, and strategy results are shown as hypothetical.
Track record
| Claimed win rate | No platform-wide claim; strategy results are shown as hypothetical (provider's claim) |
|---|---|
| Independently verified | No |
This is the most important point in the review. Most strategy pages show results as hypothetical: what the strategy's signals would have earned, under Collective2's assumptions on fills and costs. They are not the results of a real account. Some strategies carry a Trades Own Strategy certification, which means the manager trades the strategy from a real broker account. Prefer those.
The track record is not independently verified at platform level. Hypothetical results tend to look better than real ones, because they assume clean fills and ignore the slippage a real order meets. See Collective2 track records.
How Collective2 compares
| Collective2 | Myfxbook AutoTrade | MQL5 Signals | ZuluTrade | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Founded | 2001 | 2009 | 2000 | 2007 |
| Main platform fee | USD 49 a month | Free | Free | Free |
| Paid strategy or signal fee | Usually USD 50 to 200 | None | USD 30 to 1,000, set by each provider | None |
| Trustpilot | 1.6 | 2.4 | 1.2 | 1.3 |
- Myfxbook AutoTrade charges no platform fee and focuses on forex and CFDs, with brokers usually charging through a wider spread.
- MQL5 Signals offers free and paid MetaTrader signals with a monthly subscription per signal.
- ZuluTrade is free to use, with costs inside broker pricing.
Collective2 is the only one of the four with a real multi-asset range, including futures and options. It is also the most expensive at the platform level outside the EU. Choose it for the markets, not for the price.
Scaling and account size
AutoTrade lets you scale a strategy up or down relative to the manager's own position sizes. Scaling is where many copiers go wrong.
An illustrative example. A futures strategy is run on a 50,000 account and buys one contract at a time. You link a 25,000 account and set scaling to 100%, so you also buy one contract. Each move now hits your account twice as hard as the manager's, in percentage terms. A 10% drawdown on the strategy page becomes a 20% drawdown for you. Set scaling so your position sizes match your account size, and check what that means in contracts or lots before the first trade.
Some markets cannot be scaled finely. One futures contract cannot be split, so small accounts may be unable to follow a futures strategy at a sensible size at all.
Futures and options carry extra risk
Collective2's range is its main draw, but futures and options carry risks that forex copiers may not expect. Futures are leveraged and can lose more than the margin posted. Short option positions can lose many times the premium collected. A strategy that sells options can show a long run of small gains and then one very large loss. When you read a strategy page, check which instruments it trades and whether it sells options.
Collective2 Europe in practice
For EU investors, Collective2 Europe removes the AutoTrade plan fee and runs accounts through MEXEM and Interactive Brokers. Strategy fees and broker commissions still apply. Work out the strategy fee against your account size in the same way, since it is now the main fixed cost.
Reading a strategy page
- Certification first. Filter for strategies traded from a real account.
- Drawdown before return. A large drawdown shows what you would have had to sit through.
- Length of history. Prefer years, across different markets, over a few strong months.
- Trade frequency. Frequent trading adds broker costs.
- Minimum capital. Many strategies state a recommended account size. Below it, scaling may distort results.
- Fees as a share of capital. Work out the yearly fee against your account size before you subscribe.
Customer support
Support is by live chat, email, phone. Collective2 does not publish support hours.
Customer support
| Channels | live chat, email, phone |
|---|
For deposits, withdrawals and account questions, contact your broker. For strategy and AutoTrade questions, contact Collective2.
What users say
Collective2 scores 1.6 on Trustpilot from 33 reviews.
Ratings around the web
| Trustpilot | 1.6 / 5 from 33 reviews |
|---|
That is a low score from a small sample. Complaints about copy services often reflect strategy losses, but repeated complaints about billing or AutoTrade errors deserve attention. Read the newest ones.
Risks and open questions
Check before you sign up
- Hypothetical results can differ widely from what an AutoTrade account achieves after fills and fees.
- Only strategies with the Trades Own Strategy certification are traded from a real account by the manager.
- Fees are charged monthly whatever the strategy returns.
- Protection depends on the broker account you link, not on Collective2.
- Hypothetical results. Most published results are not from real accounts.
- Fixed fees. Monthly plan and strategy fees are charged whatever the result.
- No refund policy is published.
- Broker protection. Safety depends on the broker you link.
- Strategy risk. You inherit each manager's leverage and methods, in markets like futures and options where losses can be large.
Who Collective2 suits
Collective2 suits experienced traders with larger accounts who want strategies in futures, options or stocks as well as forex, already hold or will open an account at a supported broker, and will filter for strategies traded from real accounts. EU investors get the best deal, with free AutoTrade.
It does not suit beginners, small accounts where fees would eat most of any return, or anyone who reads hypothetical results as a track record. If you try it, browse on the free account first, pick only certified strategies, and work out the yearly fees against your account size before subscribing. See also how Collective2 works.
Compare it head to head:
User reviews
No reviews of Collective2 yet. Share your experience below.
Frequently asked questions
How does Collective2 work?
Strategy managers publish trading strategies on Collective2. You subscribe to a strategy and use AutoTrade to copy its trades into your own account at a supported broker.
How much does Collective2 cost?
Outside the EU you pay a monthly AutoTrade plan, priced by how many strategies you follow, plus each strategy's own monthly fee and your broker's costs. In the EU, AutoTrade is free for investors through Collective2 Europe, but strategy fees still apply.
Are Collective2 results real?
Results on strategy pages are labeled hypothetical. Only strategies with the Trades Own Strategy certification are traded by the manager from a real broker account.
Which brokers work with Collective2?
Partners include Interactive Brokers, Tradovate, AMP, FXCM and StoneX, among others. In the EU, accounts are opened through MEXEM, which acts as an introducing broker to Interactive Brokers.
Does Collective2 hold my money?
No. Your money stays at the broker you link, and that broker's regulation decides your protection.