Skip to content
Menu

Collective2 Win Rate: What It Really Means

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated · How we make money

Collective2 does not publish a single win rate for its service, so there is no headline figure to check.

Why win rate is not enough

Profit depends on win rate and on the size of wins against losses. A 70% win rate loses money if each loss is three times the size of each win. Ask for the average win, average loss, maximum drawdown and the number of trades behind the figure.

Collective2 in brief

Collective2 is a New York strategy marketplace running since 2001, where you subscribe to trading strategies in stocks, options, futures and forex and copy them into a linked broker account with AutoTrade. It covers more markets and brokers than most signal services, but costs stack up from a USD 49 to 299 monthly AutoTrade plan plus each strategy's own fee, and most results on strategy pages are hypothetical.

Back to the full Collective2 review.

How Collective2 compares on claimed win rate

8 of 14 signals providers publish a claimed win rate.

Signals providerClaimed win rateVisit
Collective2No platform-wide claimVisit
CryptoSignals.org82% success rateVisit
cTrader CopyNo platform-wide win rate publishedVisit
DarwinexNo win-rate claimVisit
FXLeaders50.18% average win rate across 1,160 signals (provider's own signals report, updated 12…Visit
MQL5 SignalsNo platform-wide win rate publishedVisit
Myfxbook AutoTradeNo platform-wide win rate publishedVisit
ZuluTrade73% of our investors make profit when copying top leaders correctly (provider's own…Visit

Win rates are the provider's own figures. Without the average win, average loss and maximum drawdown, a high win rate says little about whether copying would make money.

Frequently asked questions

Is a high win rate enough?

No. A high win rate with small wins and large losses can still lose money. Look at risk-reward and drawdown too.

How can I verify a track record?

Look for a third-party verified account, such as a Myfxbook or FX Blue link, with the full trade history.