Collective2 Track Records and Hypothetical Results
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated · How we make money
On this page
Collective2 makes no platform-wide claim, and strategy results are shown as hypothetical. That matters more than any single number. A hypothetical result shows what a strategy's signals would have earned under the platform's assumptions about fills and costs. It is not the result of a real account. Some strategies carry the Trades Own Strategy certification, which means the manager trades them from a real broker account. The track record is not independently verified at platform level. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
Track record
| Claimed win rate | No platform-wide claim; strategy results are shown as hypothetical (provider's claim) |
|---|---|
| Independently verified | No |
What "hypothetical" means
When a strategy manager sends a trade, Collective2 records it and calculates a result as if the trade had been filled at a modelled price, with modelled costs. The strategy page then shows that calculated history. It is not a broker statement.
Hypothetical results tend to flatter a strategy, for three reasons:
- Fills. A modelled fill assumes you got the price. Real orders meet slippage, especially in fast markets, thin options or at the open.
- Costs. Modelled commissions may not match your broker's, and financing on leveraged positions may be left out or estimated.
- Size. A real order large enough to matter can move a thin market. A modelled order does not.
What the certification adds
A strategy with the Trades Own Strategy certification is traded by its manager from a real broker account. That does not prove the strategy will work, but it does show the manager has real money in it and that its trades are executable. Filter for these strategies first, and treat uncertified ones as ideas rather than track records.
A worked example
Illustrative figures. A strategy page shows a hypothetical return of 30% in a year, on a 50,000 model account, with 400 trades.
- Assume real slippage averages 0.05% of trade value per trade, and the strategy uses its full capital on each trade.
- 400 trades × 0.05% = 20 percentage points of drag.
- Add a 100 monthly strategy fee and a 49 monthly plan, about 3.6% of 50,000 a year.
- The real-world result could fall from 30% to roughly 6%, before commissions.
The exact numbers vary, but the direction does not. The more often a strategy trades, the more the hypothetical figures overstate what a copier gets.
How to read a strategy page
Certification. Check for real-account trading before anything else.
Drawdown. The largest fall from peak to low shows what you would have had to sit through. Read it before the return. See drawdown.
History length. Prefer strategies with several years across calm and volatile markets.
Trade frequency. Frequent traders suffer more from slippage and commissions.
Instruments. Strategies that sell options can show smooth gains for a long time and then a very large loss.
Win rate against payoff. Compare the average win with the average loss. A very high win rate with rare, very large losses is a warning sign.
Stated capital. Check the account size the strategy is run on, and how your scaling compares.
Rankings and survivorship
Strategy rankings reward recent strong runs. Strategies that did badly are often stopped or hidden, so the ones you see are survivors. A strategy at the top of a leaderboard after a few months is more likely to have taken large risks than to have found a lasting edge.
Costs and your results
Fees are charged monthly whatever the result: USD 49 for one strategy on AutoTrade outside the EU, plus Usually USD 50 to 200 for each strategy. None of this is reflected in a hypothetical return. See how Collective2 works.
Reviews
Collective2 scores 1.6 on Trustpilot from 33 reviews. A low score from a small sample proves little either way, but it is worth reading for complaints about billing and copying errors.
Related pages
Back to the full Collective2 review.
Frequently asked questions
Are Collective2 results real?
Results on strategy pages are labeled hypothetical. They show what a strategy's signals would have earned under Collective2's assumptions, not a real account's results.
What is the Trades Own Strategy certification?
It shows that the manager trades the strategy from a real broker account. It is the strongest evidence a Collective2 strategy page offers.
Does Collective2 claim a win rate?
No. It makes no platform-wide win rate claim.
Why do my results differ from the strategy page?
Your fills, commissions, timing and scaling differ from the hypothetical figures, and hypothetical results usually assume clean fills.