The Costs of Signals and Copy Trading
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
In this lesson you will learn
- List the fees charged by signal and copy trading services
- Explain how performance fees and high-water marks work
- Calculate net returns after all fees and trading costs
- Judge whether a subscription makes sense for your account size
The copy trading lesson explained how to choose and manage a strategy. This lesson covers what it costs. You will learn the main fee types for signal services and copy trading, how performance fees and high-water marks work, how to calculate net returns after every cost, and how account size changes whether a service makes sense.
Types of fees
Subscription fees
A fixed amount per month, quarter or year, common for signal groups and some copy services. You pay whether the signals make money or not.
Performance fees
A share of profits, often calculated monthly or quarterly. It is a form of profit split between you and the provider. It aligns the provider's income with your results, at least partly.
Management fees
A yearly percentage of the amount you allocate, charged whether the strategy gains or loses. Usually charged in small amounts over the year.
Per-trade or volume fees
Some services charge per trade copied or per lot traded. These grow with trading activity.
Spread markups and broker arrangements
Some copy platforms charge no visible fee but use wider spreads or higher commissions on copy accounts. Some providers are paid by brokers as an introducing broker, based on follower trading volume. You pay these costs indirectly through each trade.
Normal trading costs still apply
On top of service fees, every copied or signal-based trade pays normal trading costs:
- spread
- commission, if your account charges it
- slippage, often larger when copying because of delays
- overnight swap charges on positions held past the daily rollover
Subscriptions and account size
A fixed subscription costs the same whatever your account size, so it weighs heavily on small accounts.
Worked example (illustrative numbers): a subscription of 50 US dollars a month is 600 a year.
- On a 2,000 dollar account: 600 ÷ 2,000 = 30% of the account per year, just to cover the fee.
- On a 20,000 dollar account: 3%.
- On a 100,000 dollar account: 0.6%.
For a small account, the signals would need to produce a very high return just to break even on the subscription, before trading costs.
Performance fees and high-water marks
A performance fee charges a share of profit. A high-water mark means the fee is charged only on new profits above the account's previous peak. Without one, you could pay fees on recovering losses you already suffered.
Worked example (illustrative numbers): 20% performance fee with a high-water mark, starting at 10,000 US dollars.
- Month 1: account rises to 11,000. Profit above the peak: 1,000. Fee: 200. Account after fee: 10,800. New peak: 10,800.
- Month 2: account falls to 10,000. No fee.
- Month 3: account rises to 10,700. Still below the 10,800 peak. No fee.
- Month 4: account rises to 11,300. Profit above the peak: 500. Fee: 100.
Without a high-water mark, month 3 might have charged a fee on the 700 recovery, even though the account had not made new profits. Always check whether a high-water mark applies.
Calculating net returns
Add every cost before judging a service.
Worked example (illustrative numbers): you allocate 10,000 US dollars to a copied strategy for a year.
- Provider's gross gain: 15% = 1,500
- Extra slippage and timing differences on your account: −1.5% = −150
- Trading costs (spread and commission) not reflected in the provider's figures: −2% = −200
- Management fee: 1% = −100
- Gain after these costs: 1,050
- Performance fee: 20% of 1,050 = −210
Net result: about +840, or 8.4%, compared with the 15% headline. If the strategy had lost money, the management fee and trading costs would have made the loss larger.
Hidden and changing costs
Watch for:
- fees that rise after an introductory period
- "VIP" tiers that require further payments
- automatic renewals that are hard to cancel
- required brokers with higher costs than you would otherwise pay
- withdrawal or inactivity fees on the linked account
Read the terms of both the service and the broker.
Free services are not always free
Free signal groups and free copy platforms still need income. Common sources are broker referral commissions, wider spreads, upselling paid tiers or selling courses. Some free groups exist mainly to send followers to a specific broker, sometimes an unregulated one, as covered in the unregulated providers lesson. Understand how a free service makes money before you follow it.
Is it worth it?
A service is only worth paying for if, after all fees and trading costs, it is likely to add more than it costs, compared with simpler alternatives such as learning to trade yourself or long-term investing in low-cost funds. Use realistic assumptions:
- assume your results will be lower than the provider's posted results
- assume future returns may be lower than past returns
- include every fee and cost
The cost of trade calculator helps estimate trading costs.
Compare against a simple alternative
A useful test is to compare a service's expected net result with a simple, low-cost alternative over the same period. For example, compare it with doing nothing, holding cash, or investing in a broad, low-cost index fund, as covered in the stock trading course. If, after all fees and realistic costs, the service is not clearly better than the simple option, and it carries more risk, the service is hard to justify.
Key takeaways
- Services charge subscriptions, performance fees, management fees, per-trade fees or hidden markups.
- Normal trading costs and extra slippage apply on top of service fees.
- Fixed subscriptions weigh most on small accounts.
- A high-water mark stops performance fees being charged on recovered losses.
- Calculate net returns after every cost, and assume your results will trail the provider's.
Check your understanding
1. A signal subscription costs 50 US dollars a month. On a 2,000 US dollar account, what return is needed just to cover it over a year?
- A. 2.5%
- B. 15%
- C. 30%
- D. 50%
Show answer
C. 30%
2. What does a high-water mark do in a performance fee?
- A. Charges fees on every gain, including recovery of past losses
- B. Charges performance fees only on new profits above the previous peak
- C. Doubles the fee
- D. Removes trading costs
Show answer
B. Charges performance fees only on new profits above the previous peak
3. Why might a copy trading service with no subscription still be expensive?
- A. Costs may be built into wider spreads or other fees
- B. Free services never cost anything
- C. Because profits are taxed twice
- D. Because stops are not allowed
Show answer
A. Costs may be built into wider spreads or other fees