Skip to content
Menu

The Risks of Following Others

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Risk 1: Past performance does not predict the future
  2. Risk 2: Rankings and selection
  3. Risk 3: Hidden risk
  4. Risk 4: Execution and crowding
  5. Risk 5: Provider and platform risk
  6. Risk 6: Dependency
  7. Risk 7: Psychology
  8. Risk 8: Binary options and signals combined
  9. A personal plan for following others
  10. When following others can make sense
  11. Key takeaways

In this lesson you will learn

  • List the main risks of following signals and copy traders
  • Explain why past performance and rankings can mislead
  • Recognize the psychological traps of following others
  • Build a personal plan that limits these risks

This final lesson brings the course together. You have learned how binary options work, why many regulators banned them, how to spot unregulated providers, and how signals, verification, copy trading and costs work. Now you will look at the risks of following other people's trades as a whole, and finish with a personal plan to limit them. Trading always carries a risk of loss, and following others does not remove it.

Risk 1: Past performance does not predict the future

Every record is history. A strategy that did well may stop working because markets change, because the provider changes behavior, or because past results were partly luck. A short record is especially unreliable. Treat any record as evidence of how a strategy behaved, not a forecast of how it will behave.

Risk 2: Rankings and selection

Copy platforms and signal directories often rank providers by recent returns. This creates two problems:

  • High risk ranks well in good times. A provider using high leverage or a martingale approach can show excellent returns until a large loss.
  • Survivorship. You see the providers who are still doing well, not the many who failed and disappeared. The top of a ranking is partly the lucky survivors of a large group.

Worked example (illustrative scenario): 1,000 providers each make random trades. After a year, by chance alone, some will have strong results and top the rankings. Followers who choose from the top list are selecting on luck, not skill. Long records, drawdown checks and an understandable method help separate skill from luck, though never perfectly.

ExampleEach dot = 10 providersTop of the rankingstrong year, partly by chanceStill trading, averageFailed and disappearednever shown in the listFollowers who pick fromthe top list may beselecting on luck
A ranking shows the lucky survivors of a large group, not the many who failed and disappeared, so the top of a list can be selected on luck.

Risk 3: Hidden risk

Some strategies look smooth because the risk is hidden:

  • trades held without stop-losses until they recover
  • averaging down or grid systems that add to losing positions
  • balance curves that hide large open losses, as explained in the verified track records lesson

These strategies can fail suddenly and severely. Always look at maximum drawdown, equity curves and position sizes, not only the gain.

Risk 4: Execution and crowding

Your results depend on execution: timing, slippage, spreads and scaling. When many followers copy the same trades, especially in markets with lower liquidity, their combined orders can move prices and worsen fills for everyone. Your results will usually trail the provider's, as the costs lesson showed.

Risk 5: Provider and platform risk

  • The provider can change strategy, stop trading, or behave recklessly after a losing period.
  • The provider may have conflicts of interest, such as broker commissions.
  • The platform or broker may change terms, fees or availability.
  • If the provider or platform is unregulated, you may have little protection, as covered in the unregulated providers lesson.

Risk 6: Dependency

Following others can feel easier than learning to trade. But if you cannot judge whether a strategy is still working, you depend entirely on someone else's decisions. When a strategy hits a drawdown, you will not know whether to stay or leave. Building your own basic knowledge, for example through the forex basics and risk management courses, helps you judge what you follow.

Risk 7: Psychology

Following others does not remove the emotional traps covered in the trading psychology course:

  • FOMO: joining a provider after a big winning run, often near the peak of their performance.
  • Recency bias: dropping a provider after a few losses, or adding more after a few wins.
  • Loss aversion: refusing to stop copying a failing strategy because stopping makes the loss real.
  • Overconfidence: increasing allocation after a good month.
  • Chasing: switching between providers repeatedly, often buying high and leaving low.

Worked example (illustrative scenario): a follower joins a provider after a strong three months, during which most of the provider's gains occurred. The next three months bring a normal drawdown, and the follower leaves at the low. The provider's full six-month record is positive, but the follower's experience is a loss. Planning entries and exits in advance reduces this risk.

Risk 8: Binary options and signals combined

Binary options signal services combine several risks: a product with a built-in disadvantage, as the payouts lesson showed; very short expiries close to random; frequent links to unregulated platforms; and win-rate claims that are hard to verify. This combination carries particularly high risk.

A personal plan for following others

  1. Use only money you can afford to lose, kept separate from savings and long-term investments.
  2. Check regulation of the platform and broker on the regulator's own register.
  3. Choose providers carefully, using long, verified, live records, tolerable drawdowns and clear risk management.
  4. Calculate net results after all fees and costs before committing.
  5. Start small and increase only after watching results on your own account.
  6. Set protection limits, such as an equity stop and maximum trade size.
  7. Write exit rules in advance: when you will stop copying or following.
  8. Review regularly, comparing your results with the provider's and checking for changes in behavior.
  9. Keep learning, so you can judge what you follow.

When following others can make sense

None of these risks means that following others is always wrong. Some traders use signals as a learning tool, or copy a small amount into a carefully checked strategy while they build their own skills. The difference lies in the approach: small allocations, verified records, clear limits and regular review, instead of large deposits driven by promises of easy returns.

Key takeaways

  • Past performance does not predict future results, and short records are especially unreliable.
  • Rankings often reward risk and luck; survivorship hides the many providers who failed.
  • Hidden risk, execution differences and provider changes can all hurt followers.
  • Dependency and psychological traps such as FOMO and recency bias apply to followers too.
  • A written personal plan with limits, exit rules and regular review reduces these risks.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why can provider rankings be misleading?

    • A. They often reward recent high returns, which may come from high risk or luck
    • B. They are always fully audited
    • C. They show only losses
    • D. They are set by regulators
    Show answer

    A. They often reward recent high returns, which may come from high risk or luck

  2. 2. What is dependency risk?

    • A. Relying on someone else's decisions without the skill to judge or replace them
    • B. Using too many stop-losses
    • C. Trading only one market
    • D. A broker's margin rule
    Show answer

    A. Relying on someone else's decisions without the skill to judge or replace them

  3. 3. Which is a sensible limit when following others?

    • A. Allocate only money you can afford to lose and set an equity stop
    • B. Copy every top-ranked provider at once
    • C. Remove all stop-losses
    • D. Increase allocation after each loss
    Show answer

    A. Allocate only money you can afford to lose and set an equity stop