What Trading Signals Are
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
In this lesson you will learn
- Define a trading signal and list what a complete signal includes
- Describe manual, automated and indicator-based signals
- Explain how signals are delivered and acted on
- Distinguish signals from copy trading and managed accounts
The first four lessons covered binary options. The rest of the course covers a related topic: following other people's trades through signals and copy trading. This lesson explains what a trading signal is, what a complete signal should contain, the main types of service, and how signals differ from copy trading. The next lesson shows how to judge a provider.
What a trading signal is
A trading signal is a suggestion to place a specific trade, sent by a person, a group or a program. It tells you what to trade, in which direction, and at what prices. You then decide whether to place the trade yourself.
Signals are offered for forex, indices, commodities, shares, crypto and binary options. Some are free; many are paid by subscription.
What a complete signal includes
A usable signal gives enough detail to place and manage the trade without guessing:
- Market: for example EUR/USD or a stock index.
- Direction: buy or sell.
- Entry: a price or price zone, and whether it is a market or pending order.
- Stop-loss: where the trade is closed if wrong.
- Take-profit: one or more targets.
- Timing: when the signal is valid, and when to cancel it if not triggered.
- Management updates: for example, when to move the stop or close early.
Worked example (illustrative signal): "Sell GBP/USD at 1.2700–1.2710. Stop-loss 1.2750. Take-profit 1 at 1.2640, take-profit 2 at 1.2600. Valid until 16:00 GMT." This tells you the trade, the risk (about 40 to 50 pips) and the targets. A signal that only says "Sell GBP/USD now" leaves out the most important parts.
For binary options signals, the signal usually gives the asset, direction (high or low) and expiry time.
What signals leave to you
Even a complete signal does not decide:
- Position size. You must size the trade from your own account and risk per trade. The position size calculator turns the signal's stop distance into a lot size for your account.
- Whether the trade suits your plan, your markets and your other open positions.
- Execution. You place the order, at your broker, at the price you can get.
A signal provider's results are usually shown in pips or percentages. Your results depend on your size, your broker's costs and your timing.
Types of signal
Manual signals
A person or team analyzes the market and sends trades. They may use technical analysis, fundamental analysis or both. Quality depends entirely on the analyst's skill, consistency and honesty.
Automated signals
A program, such as an algorithm or Expert Advisor, generates signals from fixed rules. These are consistent, but the rules may be curve-fitted to past data. The algo trading lesson explains this risk.
Indicator alerts
Some services sell alerts based on a single indicator or pattern, such as a moving average crossover. These are simple to follow but are usually just mechanical rules you could test yourself.
How signals are delivered
- messaging apps and chat groups
- email or text messages
- dedicated apps or websites
- inside trading platforms, such as signal services built into MetaTrader
Speed matters. If a signal arrives late or you see it late, the price may have moved, and the entry, stop and target may no longer make sense. The FOMO lesson explains why chasing a late entry worsens the trade.
Why your results differ from the provider's
Worked example (illustrative numbers): a provider posts a buy at 1.1000 with a target at 1.1030, and reports +30 pips. You receive the signal two minutes later and buy at 1.1006, paying a 1-pip spread. The target is hit, and your gain is 24 pips minus costs. On a losing trade, slippage and delays can make your loss larger than the provider's. Over many trades, these small differences add up.
Signals versus copy trading and managed accounts
- Signals: you receive a suggestion and decide whether to place the trade yourself.
- Copy trading: trades are copied into your account automatically, scaled to your settings. The copy trading lesson covers it.
- Managed accounts: a professional trades your account for you, usually under a formal agreement and, in many countries, with regulatory permission.
Each step moves more control away from you, which brings convenience but also more dependence on someone else's decisions.
Signals as a learning tool
Some traders use signals to learn, not just to follow. If a provider explains the reasoning behind each signal, you can compare it with your own analysis and track which ideas work. Treat each signal as a hypothesis to test, not an instruction to obey.
Questions to ask about any signal service
Before following any signal service, find out:
- Does every signal include a stop-loss and a target?
- How quickly are signals delivered, and at what times of day?
- Are losing signals published as clearly as winners?
- Does the service require you to use a specific broker?
The answers will shape how useful the service can be, and the next lesson shows how to judge the provider behind it.
Key takeaways
- A trading signal is a suggestion to place a specific trade, which you decide whether to take.
- A complete signal includes market, direction, entry, stop-loss, take-profit and timing.
- You remain responsible for position size, fit with your plan and execution.
- Signals can be manual, automated or indicator-based, delivered by apps, groups or platforms.
- Your results will differ from the provider's because of timing, costs and size.
Check your understanding
1. Which items should a complete trade signal include?
- A. Only the market name
- B. Market, direction, entry, stop-loss and take-profit, plus timing
- C. Only the expected profit
- D. Only a chart screenshot
Show answer
B. Market, direction, entry, stop-loss and take-profit, plus timing
2. What is the main difference between a signal and copy trading?
- A. With signals you decide and place the trade yourself; copy trading places trades automatically
- B. Signals are always free
- C. Copy trading never has fees
- D. There is no difference
Show answer
A. With signals you decide and place the trade yourself; copy trading places trades automatically
3. Why might your result differ from the signal provider's posted result?
- A. Different entry timing, prices, spreads and position size
- B. Results are always identical
- C. Because signals have no prices
- D. Because stop-losses are not allowed
Show answer
A. Different entry timing, prices, spreads and position size