ECN Forex Accounts: How They Work and Which Brokers Offer Them
By Chad Smith · Updated
On this page
An ECN account gives you prices from a network of liquidity providers with little or no markup, and charges a commission per lot traded. It is built for active traders who want the lowest all-in cost and market execution. The brokers below have an account they class as ECN.
A broker appears here if one of its accounts has the type "ecn". Many brokers sell the same pricing model under the name "raw" instead, so also see raw spread accounts.
What ECN means
ECN stands for electronic communication network, a system that matches buy and sell orders from many market participants. In retail forex, an "ECN account" usually means the broker passes your order to one or more liquidity providers, such as banks and non-bank market makers, and shows you the best prices they quote.
Because the broker is not adding a markup to the spread, it earns money from a fixed commission per lot. Spreads on major pairs can fall close to zero at busy times and widen when liquidity is thin, such as around the daily rollover or major news.
ECN vs market maker
The difference is about who takes the other side of your trade.
- A market maker quotes its own prices and may take the other side of client trades. It earns from the spread and, in some cases, from client losses.
- An ECN or no dealing desk broker passes orders on to liquidity providers. It earns from commission and does not depend on clients losing.
In practice, many brokers run a hybrid model, keeping some flow in-house and passing some on. The account name does not prove how a broker handles your orders. The broker's order execution policy, required under most top-tier licenses, is the document to read. Our guide to ECN vs market maker explains the models in more detail.
Brokers with an ECN account
- VantageMin deposit USD 504.8Visit
BlackBull MarketsMin deposit USD 04.6Visit- PU PrimeMin deposit USD 204.4Visit
Moneta MarketsMin deposit USD 504.4Visit
RoboForexMin deposit USD 104.3Visit- IronFXMin deposit USD 504.2Visit
- FxProMin deposit USD 1004.1Visit
- FXOpenMin deposit USD 1004.0Visit
- D PrimeMin deposit USD 1003.3Visit
AMarketsMin deposit USD 1003.3Visit
The ECN accounts differ mainly in minimum deposit and commission:
- BlackBull Markets ECN Prime: average EUR/USD spread of 0.16 pips plus 6 USD per lot round turn, with a minimum deposit of 0. See the BlackBull Markets review.
- Moneta Markets Prime ECN: Spreads from 0.0 pips on majors plus USD 3 per lot per side. Minimum deposit 50 USD. Its Ultra ECN tier cuts the commission for balances from 20,000 USD. See the Moneta Markets review.
- Vantage Pro ECN: USD 1.50 per lot per side on forex and precious metals. Aimed at professional traders and money managers. It requires 10,000 USD. Vantage's Raw ECN account offers similar pricing from a lower deposit. See the Vantage review.
- RoboForex ECN: Commission USD 20 per USD 1 million traded per side. Leverage up to 1:500. See the RoboForex review.
- FxPro cTrader: Commission USD 35 per USD 1 million traded per side, so the per-lot amount depends on the exchange rate. Hedging accounts only. See the FxPro review.
- AMarkets ECN: commission of 5 USD per lot round turn. See the AMarkets review.
Notice that some brokers charge commission per lot and others per million traded. Per-million pricing changes with the exchange rate, so convert it to a per-lot figure before you compare.
ECN-style pricing at Pepperstone
Pepperstone classes its low-cost account as raw rather than ECN, but the pricing model is the same. Its Razor account publishes an average EUR/USD spread of 0.13 pips plus 7 USD per lot round turn, from a minimum deposit of 0 USD.
How to compare ECN accounts
Compare the all-in cost of a round-turn trade, not the spread or the commission alone.
- Take the broker's average spread on the pair you trade, not the "from" figure. A spread "from 0.0 pips" is the best moment, not the norm.
- Convert the spread into money. On EUR/USD, one pip on one standard lot is worth 10 US dollars.
- Add the round-turn commission per lot.
- Repeat for each broker and compare the totals.
Also check:
- Execution model. Read the order execution policy for how orders are routed.
- Platforms. Some ECN accounts are only available on certain platforms, such as cTrader or MetaTrader 5.
- Minimum deposit. Low-commission tiers can need large balances.
- Regulator. The protection you get depends on the entity, not on the account. Check the regulators pages.
- Swap-free option. If you need it, check whether the ECN account can be made swap-free. See Islamic accounts.
Common misunderstandings about ECN accounts
"ECN means no conflict of interest." Not always. The name is a marketing label, not a regulated term. A broker can call an account ECN and still internalize some orders. The execution policy and the broker's regulatory disclosures tell you more than the account name.
"Zero spread means zero cost." The commission is the cost. A zero spread with a high commission can cost more than a small spread with a low commission.
"ECN accounts never slip." Market execution fills at the best available price. In fast markets that price can be worse, or better, than the one on your screen. This is slippage, and it happens on every execution model.
"ECN is only for professionals." Several brokers in the list above offer ECN pricing from a small deposit, and retail clients keep their normal protections.
Who should use an ECN account
ECN accounts suit:
- Scalpers and day traders, whose costs add up quickly.
- Algorithmic traders running Expert Advisors.
- Traders who want transparent pricing that shows the real market spread.
They are less suited to beginners who trade rarely, because the commission line on each trade can be confusing and the saving is small at low volume. A standard account is simpler for that.
Remember that a cheaper account does not change the risk. CFDs are leveraged, and most retail accounts lose money. Lower costs only help if your strategy has an edge.
Related pages
- Best ECN forex brokers
- Raw spread accounts
- Forex brokers with low spreads
- Spreads and commissions explained
- Cashback and rebates, which can lower ECN costs further for high-volume traders
Frequently asked questions
What is an ECN account in forex?
An ECN account routes your orders to a network of liquidity providers and shows their prices with little or no markup. The broker charges a commission per lot instead of widening the spread.
Is an ECN account better than a standard account?
For active traders it is usually cheaper, because the total of a raw spread plus commission tends to be lower than a standard spread. For occasional traders the saving is small, and a standard account is simpler.
Do ECN accounts have requotes?
ECN accounts use market execution, so orders are filled at the best available price rather than requoted. In fast markets that price can differ from the one you saw, which is called slippage.
Is an ECN broker the same as a no dealing desk broker?
They are closely related. An ECN broker is a type of no dealing desk broker that passes orders to liquidity providers. The labels are used loosely, so read the broker's order execution policy to see how it actually handles your trades.
Why do some ECN accounts need a high deposit?
Some brokers reserve their lowest commission for large balances, so the top ECN tier has a high minimum deposit. Other brokers offer ECN pricing from a small deposit.